Recent revelations from The Order: 1886 developers have unveiled ambitious plans for what was meant to be a groundbreaking trilogy. The 2015 PS4 exclusive, developed by Ready at Dawn, was just the beginning of a much larger narrative set in an alternate steampunk London. However, despite early work on a sequel, the project was ultimately shelved, leaving fans to wonder what might have been.

Set in a meticulously crafted Victorian-era London with supernatural elements, The Order: 1886 delivered stunning visuals and a cinematic experience. Players took on the role of Sir Galahad, navigating linear paths and engaging in cover-based combat. While praised for its artistry, the game faced criticism for its short length and restrictive gameplay, factors that ultimately impacted its commercial success.

In an interview with VGC, Ru Weerasuriya, the game's creative director, shared that the sequel was already in early development. The team had drafted a 10-page pitch outlining expanded combat sequences and the introduction of multiplayer—a feature originally intended for the first game. Unfortunately, the lukewarm reception of The Order: 1886 led Sony to abandon the project, dashing hopes for a continuation.

Despite the initial setback, fans held onto hope. In 2021, Sony renewed the trademark for The Order: 1886, sparking speculation about a revival. However, these hopes were crushed when Ready at Dawn, the studio behind the game, was shut down by Meta in 2024 amid industry-wide layoffs. The closure marked the end of any potential return to the franchise.

Though The Order: 1886 remains a divisive title, its legacy endures among fans who appreciated its world-building and aesthetic. The canceled sequel represents a missed opportunity to expand on its unique universe, leaving players to imagine what could have been with multiplayer and grander battles. For now, the game stands as a testament to Ready at Dawn's ambition—a vision cut short before its full potential could be realized.