Disney Dreamlight Valley players are engaged in a heated discussion about whether Gameloft should include Pocahontas, the iconic character from Disney's 1995 animated film. As a life simulation and adventure game that brings together beloved Disney and Pixar characters, Disney Dreamlight Valley has already introduced numerous heroes and villains from different franchises. However, the potential inclusion of Pocahontas has sparked controversy, with some players advocating for her addition while others argue it would be disrespectful to Indigenous communities.

Originally launched in early access in September 2022, Disney Dreamlight Valley fully released in late 2023, allowing players to create their own thriving communities alongside classic Disney characters. The game has seen multiple updates in 2024 and 2025, introducing characters from Aladdin and Alice in Wonderland through expansions like the Tales of Agrabah and Wonderland Whimsy updates.

With Gameloft already introducing characters from '90s Disney films, some players are hopeful that Pocahontas and her companions will eventually join Disney Dreamlight Valley. However, others argue that the character's portrayal in the original film—which took significant creative liberties with the real-life figure Matoaka—could be seen as culturally insensitive. The film's depiction of colonization and its romanticized relationship between Pocahontas and John Smith have been criticized for glossing over historical realities.

The discussion surrounding Pocahontas is particularly divisive, even among players who identify as Native American. Some fans appreciate the representation the character provides, viewing her as a strong, independent figure who bridges cultural divides. Others, however, argue that the film's portrayal of history is problematic, with one Reddit user stating, "The social harm it does outweighs any one individual's fond memories."

Comparisons have been drawn to other Disney characters, such as Peter Pan's Tiger Lily, who may also be excluded from the game due to similar concerns. Additionally, some players have pointed out that certain characters, like Tangled's Mother Gothel, were excluded due to their potentially triggering nature, suggesting that Pocahontas could evoke similar negative emotions.